Appendix II

 

In the Western world visionaries and mystics are a good deal less common than they used to be.  There are two principal reasons for this state of affairs - a philosophical reason and a chemical reason.  In the currently fashionable picture of the universe there is no place for valid transcendental experience.  Consequently those who have had what they regard as valid transcendental experiences are looked upon with suspicion, as being either lunatics or swindlers.  To be a mystic or a visionary is no longer creditable.

      But it is not only our mental climate that is unfavourable to the visionary and the mystic; it is also our chemical environment - an environment profoundly different from that in which our forefathers passed their lives.

      The brain is chemically controlled, and experience has shown that it can be made permeable to the (biologically speaking) superfluous aspects of Mind-at-Large by modifying the (biologically speaking) normal chemistry of the body.

      For almost half of every year our ancestors ate no fruit, no green vegetables, and (since it was impossible for them to feed more than a few oxen, cows, swine, and poultry during the winter months) very little butter or fresh meat, and very few eggs.  By the beginning of each successive spring, most of them were suffering, mildly or acutely, from scurvy, due to lack of vitamin C, and pellagra, caused by a shortage in their diet of the B complex.  The distressing physical symptoms of these diseases are associated with no-less distressing psychological symptoms. [See THE BIOLOGY OF HUMAN STARVATION, by A. Keys (University of Minnesota Press, 1950); also the recent (1955) reports of the work on the role of vitamin deficiencies in mental disease carried out by Dr George Watson and his associates in Southern California.]

      The nervous system is more vulnerable than the other tissues of the body; consequently vitamin deficiencies tend to affect the state of mind before they affect, at least in any very obvious way, the skin, bones, mucous membranes, muscles, and viscera.  The first result of an inadequate diet is a lowering of the efficiency of the brain as an instrument for biological survival.  The undernourished person tends to be afflicted by anxiety, depression, hypochondria, and feelings of anxiety.  He is also liable to see visions; for when the cerebral reducing valve has its efficiency reduced, much (biologically speaking) useless material flows into consciousness from 'out there', in Mind-at-Large.

      Much of what the earlier visionaries experienced was terrifying.  To use the language of Christian theology, the Devil revealed himself in their visions and ecstasies a good deal more frequently than did God.  In an age when vitamins were deficient and a belief in Satan universal, this was not surprising.  The mental distress, associated with even mild cases of pellagra and scurvy, was deepened by fears of damnation and a conviction that the powers of evil were omnipresent.  This distress was apt to tinge with its own dark colouring the visionary material, admitted to consciousness through a cerebral valve whose efficiency had been impaired by underfeeding.  But in spite of their preoccupations with eternal punishment and in spite of their deficiency disease, spiritually minded ascetics often saw heaven and might even be aware, occasionally, of that divinely impartial One, in which the polar opposites are reconciled.  For a glimpse of beatitude, for a foretaste of unitive knowledge, no price seemed too high.  Mortification of the body may produce a host of undesirable mental symptoms; but it may also open a door into a transcendental world of Being, Knowledge, and Bliss.  That is why, in spite of its obvious disadvantages, almost all aspirants to the spiritual life have, in the past, undertaken regular courses of bodily mortification.

      So far as vitamins were concerned, every medieval winter was a long involuntary fast, and this involuntary fast was followed, during Lent, by forty days of voluntary abstinence.  Holy Week found the faithful marvellously well prepared, so far as their body chemistry was concerned, for its tremendous incitements to grief and joy, for seasonable remorse of conscience and a self-transcending identification with the risen Christ.  At this season of the highest religious excitement and the lowest vitamin intake, ecstasies and visions were almost a commonplace.  It was only to be expected.

      For cloistered contemplatives, there were several Lents in every year.  And even between fasts their diet was meagre in the extreme.  Hence those agonies of depression and scrupulosity described by so many spiritual writers; hence their frightful temptations to despair and self-slaughter.  But hence too those 'gratuitous graces', in the forms of heavenly visions and locutions, of prophetic insights, of telepathic 'discernments of spirits'.  And hence, finally, their 'infused contemplation', their 'obscure knowledge' of the One in all.

      Fasting was not the only form of physical mortification resorted to by the earlier aspirants to spirituality.  Most of them regularly used upon themselves the whip of knotted leather or even of iron wire.  These beatings were the equivalent of fairly extensive surgery without anaesthetics, and their effects on the body chemistry of the patient were considerable.  Large quantities of histamine and adrenalin were released while the whip was actually being plied; and when the resulting wounds began to fester (as wounds practically always did before the age of soap), various toxic substances, produced by the decomposition of protein, found their way into the bloodstream.  But histamine produces shock, and shock affects the mind no less profoundly than the body.  Moreover, large quantities of adrenalin may cause hallucinations, and some of the products of its decomposition are known to induce symptoms resembling those of schizophrenia.  As for toxins from wounds - these upset the enzyme systems regulating the brain, and lower its efficiency as an instrument for getting on in a world where the biologically fittest survive.  This may explain why the Curé d'Arts used to say that, in the days when he was free to flagellate himself without mercy, God would refuse him nothing.  In other words, when remorse, self-loathing, and the fear of hell release adrenalin, when self-inflicted surgery releases adrenalin and histamine, and when infected wounds release decomposed protein into the blood, the efficiency of the cerebral reducing valve is lowered and unfamiliar aspects of Mind-at-Large (including psi phenomena, visions, and, if he is philosophically and ethically prepared for it, mystical experiences) will flow into the ascetic's consciousness.

      Lent, as we have seen, followed a long period of involuntary fasting.  Analogously, the effects of self-flagellation were supplemented, in earlier times, by much involuntary absorption of decomposed protein.  Dentistry was non-existent, surgeons were executioners, and there were no safe antiseptics.  Most people, therefore, must have lived out their lives with focal infections; and focal infections, though out of fashion as the cause of all the ills that flesh is heir to, can certainly lower the efficiency of the cerebral reducing valve.

      And the moral of all this is - what?  Exponents of a Nothing-But philosophy will answer that, since changes in body chemistry can create the conditions favourable to visionary and mystical experience, visionary and mystical experience cannot be what they claim to be - what, for those who have had them, they self-evidently are.  But this, of course, is a non sequitur.

      A similar conclusion will be reached by those whose philosophy is unduly 'spiritual'.  God, they will insist, is a spirit and is to be worshipped in spirit.  Therefore an experience which is chemically conditioned cannot be an experience of the divine.  But, in one way or another, all our experiences are chemically conditioned, and if we imagine that some of them are purely 'spiritual', purely 'intellectual', purely 'aesthetic', it is merely because we have never troubled to investigate the internal chemical environment at the moment of their occurrence.  Furthermore, it is a matter of historical record that most contemplatives worked systematically to modify their body chemistry, with a view to creating the internal conditions favourable to spiritual insight.  When they were not starving themselves into low blood sugar and vitamin deficiency, or beating themselves into intoxication by histamine, adrenalin, and decomposed protein, they were cultivating insomnia and praying for long periods in uncomfortable positions, in order to create the psycho-physical symptoms of stress.  In the intervals they sang interminable psalms, thus increasing the amount of carbon dioxide in the lungs and the bloodstream, or, if they were Orientals, they did breathing exercises to accomplish the same purpose.  Today we know how to lower the efficiency of the cerebral reducing valve by direct chemical action, and without the risk of inflicting serious damage on the psycho-physical organism.  For an aspiring mystic to revert, in the present state of knowledge, to prolonged fasting and violent self-flagellation would be as senseless as it would be for an aspiring cook to behave like Charles Lamb's Chinaman, who burned down the house in order to roast a pig.  Knowing as he does (or at least as he can know, if he so desires) what are the chemical conditions of transcendental experience, the aspiring mystic should turn for technical help to the specialists - in pharmacology, in biochemistry, in physiology and neurology, in psychology and psychiatry and parapsychology.  And on their part, of course, the specialists (if any of them aspire to be genuine men of science and complete human beings) should turn, out of their respective pigeonholes, to the artist, the sibyl, the visionary, the mystic - all those, in a word, who have had experience of the Other World and who know, in their different ways, what to do with that experience.